Hayley Brownell All articles
Creative Process

The Back Room of Finished Things

Hayley Brownell
The Back Room of Finished Things

There is a shelf in my apartment that is not the graveyard of abandoned projects. I have one of those too, and we have already walked through it together. This shelf is different. Everything on it is finished.

That is the part that gets me. Not half-done. Not a folder of notes I can blame on a busy month. Finished. Edited. Printed. Mixed. Packaged. The kind of work you would put on a website if you were braver or less superstitious or simply less attached to the idea of being a person who has not yet been judged.

I call it the back room. It is mostly an IKEA Kallax, one Target storage bin, and a Google Drive folder with a name so boring I almost forget to open it. But it is a room all the same. And lately I have been standing in the doorway, taking inventory.

What Is Actually on the Shelf

Let me be specific, because vague confessions are easy and inventories are not.

There is a 42-page essay collection about moving apartments in your thirties. It has a title, a cover I designed, and three rounds of edits from a friend who was generous with her red pen. It has never been sent to a single editor or reader outside that friend.

There is a zine about unsent text messages. I printed a proof copy at a copy shop in Brooklyn, paid for the nice paper, and then put it in a drawer. It looks great. It has never been listed anywhere.

There is a small run of ceramic wall hooks I made in a studio class. Six of them. Glazed, fired, wrapped in tissue paper. I have a price in mind. I have an Etsy account. I have not connected the two.

There is a twelve-issue newsletter series called The Sunday Dispatch. I wrote all twelve. I scheduled the first one. I never hit send.

There is a deck of desk cards—prompts for creative stuckness—that I designed, got quoted for a print run, and sampled. The sample deck is on the shelf. The quote is in my email. The project is done enough to sell and unfinished enough to avoid.

And there is a short audio essay I recorded and mixed in my closet. It is eleven minutes long. I listen to it sometimes when I am cleaning. It is good. I know it is good. That is not the same as being ready.

Why Done Feels More Dangerous Than Half-Done

An abandoned project is a maybe. It still has potential. It can be anything because it is nothing yet. I can blame time, money, mood, the phase of the moon. I can say I got busy. I can say the idea needed more room.

A finished thing is a claim. It says: here is what I made, and here is what I think it is worth. That claim can be rejected. Worse, it can be ignored. A finished piece sitting on a shelf is not a failure yet, but it is one click away from becoming evidence.

I have thought about this a lot, probably too much. The abandoned work protects me from a verdict. The finished work asks for one. And somewhere along the way I decided that the safest place for a completed project is behind me, where no one can see it and no one can have an opinion.

That is not discernment. I have tried to call it discernment. I have said things like, I am waiting for the right moment, or, I want to live with it a little longer. Sometimes that is true. Often it is fear wearing a very sensible cardigan.

The Portfolio Is a Highlight Reel With a Fire Exit

My website does not show any of this. It shows the work that shipped, the projects that fit a clean narrative, the pieces I could explain at Thanksgiving without watching my uncle's face go blank. It is not a lie. It is a curated room.

But the back room is where the actual square footage is. It is where the weird stuff lives—the personal essay that names too much, the product that might not sell, the audio piece with my actual voice in it. The public portfolio is a highlight reel with a fire exit. The shelf is the rest of the building.

I think a lot of creators have this room. We just do not talk about it because it sounds like a humblebrag or a complaint. It is neither. It is a storage problem and a courage problem at the same time.

The Rent I Pay for Withholding

Here is the unglamorous part: finished work takes up space. Not just physical space, though the Kallax is not getting any bigger. Mental space. Every finished thing I do not share charges a little rent. I think about the zine when I open the drawer. I think about the newsletter when I see someone else's Sunday send. I think about the audio essay every time I clean my closet.

I am not saying every finished thing needs an audience. Some work is private. Some work is practice. Some work is just for me, and that is allowed. But I know the difference between privacy and avoidance. I know when I am protecting a piece and when I am protecting myself from the piece.

A Small, Uncomfortable Experiment

Last month I made a list of everything on the shelf and gave each item one of five labels: publish, pitch, gift, trash, or not yet. The goal was not to empty the shelf. The goal was to stop pretending it was not there.

Then I set a fifteen-minute timer and did one thing. I sent the essay collection to a friend who had asked to read it two years ago. I listed three zines for sale to three people in a group chat. I did not announce anything. I did not make a big post. I just moved one item from the back room to the front room and let it be seen.

Nothing terrible happened. One person said the zine made her cry. Another asked if I had more. I felt exposed and then, about an hour later, fine. The shelf is still a shelf. But it is starting to look less like a museum and more like a queue.

That is the goal now. Not to empty the back room or turn every finished thing into content. Just to stop letting the finished stuff rot in the dark while I call it patience. The work is done. The least I can do is let one thing out this month.

All Articles

Related Articles

I Handed My Calendar to 400 Strangers. They Fixed What I Refused To.

I Handed My Calendar to 400 Strangers. They Fixed What I Refused To.

For One Month, the Internet Named Everything I Made (My Newsletter Will Never Recover)

For One Month, the Internet Named Everything I Made (My Newsletter Will Never Recover)

Thank You Is a Full Sentence: My Ongoing Struggle With Praise, Prices, and Party Small Talk

Thank You Is a Full Sentence: My Ongoing Struggle With Praise, Prices, and Party Small Talk