Twelve Songs That Outlived the Projects They Belonged To
Photo: American Colortype Co, No restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons
I keep a playlist called The Maybe Someday Mix. Forty-one songs, no artwork, no description, and an order that has never survived a full month without being rearranged at 11 p.m. I made it in 2019 for a project I can no longer describe with a straight face. Since then it has quietly become the most accurate archive I own — not of what I finished, but of what I was absolutely certain I would.
There is one rule, and I did not write it down until 2023. If I catch myself hearing a song as the soundtrack to something I am making, that song belongs to that thing. Forever. It does not get returned when the thing stops being made.
Side A: the diner podcast
“Holocene” belongs to a podcast about closed diners. I recorded three episodes in a booth at a diner outside Springfield using a borrowed mic and a level of confidence I have not located since. I never edited them. Because Bon Iver was going to be the intro music, those opening harmonics now sound exactly like my own voice saying Episode one in a room with bad acoustics.
Three episodes exist. One is twelve minutes long. The other two are mostly me chewing.
The novel and the Billy Joel problem
“Vienna” was attached to a novel draft from 2016 — the one with the unreliable narrator and the excellent first chapter and nothing after it. I listened to that song on a loop for the entire month I was outlining, which means it is now permanently the sound of an outline.
The problem is that “Vienna” is a song people play at graduations and in car commercials, so I hear it in public, at the dentist, in a grocery store in another state, and every single time I am briefly back in a Google Doc with 41,000 words in it and no ending.
The photo series I ruined for myself
“The Trapeze Swinger” is nine minutes and forty-five seconds long, and it belongs to a photo series about a county fair I shot over two summers. Forty-two images, no edit, no website, no statement. I have never been able to listen to that song in a car with other people because I go quiet in a way that requires explanation.
What a song remembers that a folder cannot
Folders record dates. A directory called fair_series_RAW tells me when I made something but nothing about the temperature of the room I was in.
A song is a different kind of file. It stores the feeling of believing in a thing before the belief runs out, which is a specific and unrepeatable sensation. When I open a folder of abandoned work, I feel tired. When I accidentally hear the third song on this playlist, I feel like the person who was going to finish it — for about forty seconds, until I remember.
That gap between the two feelings is the most useful thing I have learned about my own process in years. The work did not fail because I stopped loving it. In most cases I stopped because the soundtrack ran out.
I tried changing the music
This spring I ran an experiment on myself. I took one project off the shelf — the county fair series, since it is the one I regret most — and gave it a brand-new playlist with zero overlap with the old one. No Iron & Wine. Nothing acoustic. Mostly loud, mostly instrumental, nothing that had ever been near the project before.
What happened was not that I finished it. What happened was that the project became a different project. With new music, the edit changed. The images I pulled were harder, less nostalgic. The statement I drafted in my head had a different voice. The thing I had been mourning turned out to be one possible version of the work, held in place by nine minutes of guitar.
I have not finished it. But it is no longer the same abandoned thing, and that turns out to be a meaningful difference. You cannot reclaim a project by changing its soundtrack. You can only find out whether you still want to make the thing underneath it.
The rest of the list, whether or not you asked
- “Nude” — the ceramics newsletter I sent exactly one issue of.
- “Fast Car” — a short film treatment that got as far as a shot list.
- “Chicago” — the application packet I rewrote nine times and never submitted.
- “Motion Picture Soundtrack” — a zine about my grandmother's kitchen that I still think about weekly.
- “The Boxer” — a pitch deck for a course I taught once, badly, to four people.
- “Landslide” — a two-year email I never sent.
- “Pink Moon” — the album I bought for a road trip to a residency I was rejected from.
- “Ceremony” — the last song I added, for a project that is currently three days old and very much alive.
What the playlist is actually for
I used to think of it as a graveyard. It is not, mostly because a graveyard implies something ended and this stuff keeps showing up uninvited.
It is closer to a tuning fork. When I am deciding whether to restart something, I do not open the folder. I open the playlist and skip to the song and pay attention to the forty seconds — do I feel like the person who was going to make it, or do I feel like someone remembering a person? If it is the second one, I put it back. If it is the first, I make a new playlist and see what the project wants to be now.
Forty-one songs. A few decisions. Two of them still alive.
That is a better return than I get on most of my file structure.