Hayley Brownell All articles
Creative Process

Twelve Songs That Outlived the Projects They Belonged To

Hayley Brownell
Twelve Songs That Outlived the Projects They Belonged To

Photo: American Colortype Co, No restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons

I keep a playlist called The Maybe Someday Mix. Forty-one songs, no artwork, no description, and an order that has never survived a full month without being rearranged at 11 p.m. I made it in 2019 for a project I can no longer describe with a straight face. Since then it has quietly become the most accurate archive I own — not of what I finished, but of what I was absolutely certain I would.

There is one rule, and I did not write it down until 2023. If I catch myself hearing a song as the soundtrack to something I am making, that song belongs to that thing. Forever. It does not get returned when the thing stops being made.

Side A: the diner podcast

“Holocene” belongs to a podcast about closed diners. I recorded three episodes in a booth at a diner outside Springfield using a borrowed mic and a level of confidence I have not located since. I never edited them. Because Bon Iver was going to be the intro music, those opening harmonics now sound exactly like my own voice saying Episode one in a room with bad acoustics.

Three episodes exist. One is twelve minutes long. The other two are mostly me chewing.

The novel and the Billy Joel problem

“Vienna” was attached to a novel draft from 2016 — the one with the unreliable narrator and the excellent first chapter and nothing after it. I listened to that song on a loop for the entire month I was outlining, which means it is now permanently the sound of an outline.

The problem is that “Vienna” is a song people play at graduations and in car commercials, so I hear it in public, at the dentist, in a grocery store in another state, and every single time I am briefly back in a Google Doc with 41,000 words in it and no ending.

The photo series I ruined for myself

“The Trapeze Swinger” is nine minutes and forty-five seconds long, and it belongs to a photo series about a county fair I shot over two summers. Forty-two images, no edit, no website, no statement. I have never been able to listen to that song in a car with other people because I go quiet in a way that requires explanation.

What a song remembers that a folder cannot

Folders record dates. A directory called fair_series_RAW tells me when I made something but nothing about the temperature of the room I was in.

A song is a different kind of file. It stores the feeling of believing in a thing before the belief runs out, which is a specific and unrepeatable sensation. When I open a folder of abandoned work, I feel tired. When I accidentally hear the third song on this playlist, I feel like the person who was going to finish it — for about forty seconds, until I remember.

That gap between the two feelings is the most useful thing I have learned about my own process in years. The work did not fail because I stopped loving it. In most cases I stopped because the soundtrack ran out.

I tried changing the music

This spring I ran an experiment on myself. I took one project off the shelf — the county fair series, since it is the one I regret most — and gave it a brand-new playlist with zero overlap with the old one. No Iron & Wine. Nothing acoustic. Mostly loud, mostly instrumental, nothing that had ever been near the project before.

What happened was not that I finished it. What happened was that the project became a different project. With new music, the edit changed. The images I pulled were harder, less nostalgic. The statement I drafted in my head had a different voice. The thing I had been mourning turned out to be one possible version of the work, held in place by nine minutes of guitar.

I have not finished it. But it is no longer the same abandoned thing, and that turns out to be a meaningful difference. You cannot reclaim a project by changing its soundtrack. You can only find out whether you still want to make the thing underneath it.

The rest of the list, whether or not you asked

What the playlist is actually for

I used to think of it as a graveyard. It is not, mostly because a graveyard implies something ended and this stuff keeps showing up uninvited.

It is closer to a tuning fork. When I am deciding whether to restart something, I do not open the folder. I open the playlist and skip to the song and pay attention to the forty seconds — do I feel like the person who was going to make it, or do I feel like someone remembering a person? If it is the second one, I put it back. If it is the first, I make a new playlist and see what the project wants to be now.

Forty-one songs. A few decisions. Two of them still alive.

That is a better return than I get on most of my file structure.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Filename Is the First Draft: A Decade of Folders I Was Afraid to Open

The Filename Is the First Draft: A Decade of Folders I Was Afraid to Open

A Field Guide to the Client Maybe: One Year of Polite Emails, Decoded

A Field Guide to the Client Maybe: One Year of Polite Emails, Decoded

The Renewal Notice Is a Performance Review: Eleven Domains, Eleven Versions of Me

The Renewal Notice Is a Performance Review: Eleven Domains, Eleven Versions of Me