Hayley Brownell All articles
Making Things

I Commissioned a Beautiful Book Nobody Is Allowed to Read

Hayley Brownell
I Commissioned a Beautiful Book Nobody Is Allowed to Read

Photo: George Lincoln Rockwell, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The book weighs one pound eleven ounces. It has a linen spine stamped in gold, a deckled edge, marbled endpapers in a green I chose from a swatch book over the course of two weeks, and a title page that reads: Maybe Someday — Drafts, 2014–2026.

It cannot be opened. The pages are bound shut along the fore-edge. To read it, you would have to destroy it.

How I ended up in a bindery in Asheville

The original idea was humbler and dumber. I was cleaning out a filing cabinet in January and found ten drafts — the first three chapters of a novel, a proposal for a podcast, a book of essays I described to someone at a party as nearly done, a residency statement, four openings of things that never got a second page. I was going to scan them and make a PDF. I have made that PDF eleven times. Nobody has ever opened it, including me.

Then I saw a bookbinder on Instagram — a one-woman shop in Asheville that does restoration work and the occasional art binding for people who want their wedding vows in leather. I emailed her with a question I could not believe I was asking: can you make something that is finished but not readable?

She wrote back in ninety minutes. “Yes. Do you want it sealed at the fore-edge or hinged with a ribbon closure?”

I have never been asked a better question about my own work.

What she actually built

We went back and forth for six weeks. She prints on a cream text stock, sets the pages, sews the signatures, and then glues the page block closed from the outside in. The book looks completely normal from the shelf. It sits on a table like a book. It has a spine, a colophon, a title page, an epigraph, page numbers.

It just does not open.

Inside the front cover she pasted a small card with the initials of all ten projects and the year each one stopped moving. My handwriting, scanned. I had forgotten I sent it.

Sealed, not burned

The cost came to $340 plus shipping both ways. I want to say that number plainly because the whole thing sounds like an art-school stunt until you put a number on it, and then it becomes a decision I made with money.

That money bought me something I had been trying to get from my own discipline for a decade: a container.

Because here is the thing about an unfinished draft in a folder. It is not neutral. It is an open tab with a small red dot on it. It waits, and while it waits it sends out a low hum that makes everything else harder to hear. I do not think I am unusual in this. I think most people who make things have a drawer that hums.

What the binder did was close the drawer. Not by finishing anything, and not by deleting anything — the words are still in there, physically present, printed and sewn and slightly heavier than they need to be. The difference is that the question is answered. It is a book. It is not a draft anymore. It is not waiting on me.

The strange relief of a permanent dead end

I expected the finished object to feel like an accusation. I expected to set it on the shelf and feel a small daily sting every time the light hit the gold spine.

Instead I felt what I can only describe as relief on a Tuesday. I brought it home, put it on the shelf between two books I have actually read, and went and worked on something current for four straight hours without once thinking about the novel.

That had not happened in years.

Connie — the binder — told me she has done versions of this before. A musician who had a score of a symphony he never finished bound into a single unplayable volume. A man who printed his divorce papers on handmade paper and boxed them. She said the same thing in three different ways: people do not want their unfinished work destroyed. They want it to stop asking.

Showing work that refuses to be shown

The interesting consequence is that this is now the most-shown thing I own. It sits out. Guests pick it up. They try to open it, which is the entire point, and then they ask me what is in it, and I have to explain ten projects I have never mentioned, to a person holding a book that will not let them check.

That is not nothing. I have spent years writing about my process and there is still almost nothing in my portfolio that shows the middle. This object shows the middle, and it does it without showing a single sentence.

It also made me realize how much of my reluctance to show work is really a reluctance to be seen in the act of not knowing. A finished piece presents a person who knew. This book presents a person who didn't, at volume, with marbled endpapers.

Would I do it again

I don't think so, and I mean that as praise of the object rather than regret. One sealed book is a statement. Two is a collection. Three is a bit.

The shelf has one thing on it that is permanently in progress and permanently done, and the two conditions have stopped fighting. I keep looking at it while I write this. It does not hum. It just sits there, heavy and green and closed, and lets me work.

All Articles

Related Articles

A Year of Library Receipts: My Checkout History as a Map of Every Rabbit Hole

A Year of Library Receipts: My Checkout History as a Map of Every Rabbit Hole

Twelve Songs That Outlived the Projects They Belonged To

Twelve Songs That Outlived the Projects They Belonged To

The Filename Is the First Draft: A Decade of Folders I Was Afraid to Open

The Filename Is the First Draft: A Decade of Folders I Was Afraid to Open